Being Qua Being: A Theory of Identity, Existence, and by Panayot Butchvarov

By Panayot Butchvarov

Are there nonexistent issues? what's the nature of informative id statements? Are the notions of crucial estate and of essence intelligible, and, if this is the case, how are they to be understood? Are person issues fabric components or clusters of characteristics? Can the account of the solidarity of a fancy entity stay away from vicious limitless regresses?

These questions have attracted common consciousness between philosophers lately, as evidenced by way of a proliferation of articles within the top philosophical journals. In Being Qua Being they obtain systematic, unified therapy, grounded in an account of the character of the applying to the area of our conceptual equipment. A imperative thesis of the publication is that the subject of id is fundamental, and that life and predication, either crucial and unintended, are to be understood when it comes to identity.

Show description

Read or Download Being Qua Being: A Theory of Identity, Existence, and Predication PDF

Best metaphysics books

Process and Reality (Gifford Lectures Delivered in the University of Edinburgh During the Session 1927-28)

Proofed test formatted as PDF for 6" ereader.
PhilosophyWritings

Process and truth used to be released the yr that Wittgenstein back to Cambridge to start the circulation often called linguistic research. Whitehead's masterpiece is every little thing that analysts despise: metaphysical, jargon-filled, and systematic. Whitehead's philosophy of language is terse: "philosophy redesigns language within the samewhat that, in a actual technological know-how, pre-existing home equipment are redesigned. "
The e-book is prepared in 5 "Parts". the 1st half supplies an summary of philosophy, its goals and strategies, including a suite of premises on which the substance of his philosophy might be outfitted. He calls this set "The Categoreal Scheme" and intends the rest of his publication to be an exposition of this scheme. His paintings is, then, "systematic" in a fashion that the twentieth century has principally rejected, and hearkens again to the nineteenth century. in truth, he does so explicitly, naming his ebook after Bradley's "Appearance and Reality", and mentioning that, regardless of their metaphysical modifications, he and Bradly come to a lot a similar conclusions.
The moment half discusses the categoreal scheme when it comes to the historical past of philosophy, with emphasis at the Empiricist culture that starts off with Locke, yet overlaying the variety of contemporary an historic philosophy. during this part he elaborates his "philosophy of organism" which sees each one genuine entity as a psycho-physical solidarity of its setting. Deeply encouraged via early twentieth century physics, Whitehead provides us with a universe that's dynamic. Grounded in Plato (Western Philosophy comprises "a sequence of footnotes to Plato"), he additionally provides us with a changeless floor for this dynamism. the result's a desirable, smooth interpretation of an old mode of thought.
The 3rd and forth elements strengthen the philosophy of organism in its personal phrases, instead of in dating to the background of philosophy or to technology. those sections are of certain curiosity to the technical thinker, and remain the subject-matter of articles and books through specialist philosophers.
The 5th and ultimate half is a rhapsodic interpretation of the philosophy he has awarded. This "Final Interpretation" has encouraged a theological circulation known as "Process Theology", and offers provocative oracles for the beginner philosopher.
This isn't a simple e-book to learn when you get into half , and it's endorsed that the reader have a few familiarity with philosophy. in spite of the fact that, the decided undergraduate or the committed novice will locate that the complexity of Whitehead's jargon isn't really in basic terms to provoke the unintiated, yet expresses a view of fact that goals to be "consistent, coherent, appropriate, and adequate". The view from inside of makes it well worth the attempt essential to input into Whitehead's universe. as soon as entered, it's a global you won't overlook.

A World for Us: The Case for Phenomenalistic Idealism

An international for Us goals to refute actual realism and determine instead a sort of idealism. actual realism, within the experience during which John Foster is aware it, takes the actual global to be anything whose life is either logically self sustaining of the human brain and metaphysically basic. Foster identifies a few difficulties for this realist view, yet his major objection is that it doesn't accord the realm the considered necessary empirical immanence.

Additional resources for Being Qua Being: A Theory of Identity, Existence, and Predication

Sample text

Translations from the Philosophical Writings of Gottlob Frege [Oxford: Basil Blackwell, 1970], p. " P. T. Geach, Reference and Generality (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1968), p. XI. Page 12 swayed by facile answers or preconceived notions. And our first task must be to identify as generally as possible, yet with reasonable clarity and especially in fresh, philosophically neutral terms, the feature of material identity statements that demands philosophical account. Frege held that although, if true, such a statement may only be about one thing, that thing may be given to us in many ways, it may be presented to us in many modes, and the subject terms of the statement express two such different ways of being given or modes of presentation, even though they refer to only one thing.

And even though an entire chapter is devoted to it, the foundation of almost all the views I shall defend, namely, the distinction between objects and entities, cannot be fully understood in abstraction from its applications to the topics discussed in the later chapters. On the other hand, these discussions might appear sketchy, perhaps even high-handed, unless regarded as intended to derive whatever substance they possess mainly from that distinction. Page 9 Chapter One The Apparent Distinctness of Identicals I I shall begin with several historical references in order to bare some of the roots of what will follow.

Even if the statement "a is the same as b" is true, we might have said, a and b are distinguishable, and this fact is the mark of a material identity statement. But then we should have sacrificed logical coherence for superficial elegance. For we must not allow that material identicals are distinguishable either in the sense that they are nonidentical or in the sense that though identical they violate the principle of the indiscernibility of identicals. And what else could we mean, at this point in our inquiry, by their distinguishability?

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.84 of 5 – based on 33 votes